TECH REVIEWStech-reviews

14 Best Augmented Reality Books for 2024

14-best-augmented-reality-books-for-2023

Introducing the 14 Best Augmented Reality Books for 2023. In this rapidly evolving digital age, augmented reality has emerged as a groundbreaking technology with immense potential. As augmented reality continues to shape various industries, from education to entertainment, staying updated with the latest trends and insights is crucial. Whether you are an enthusiast, professional, or simply curious about this captivating field, these 14 books offer a comprehensive guide to delve into augmented reality's intricacies and possibilities. From exploring its applications in gaming and virtual fashion to understanding its impact on communication and design, these carefully curated titles provide an immersive learning experience to keep you ahead of the curve in 2023.

Overall Score: 9.5/10

Dinos By LeARnLab is an augmented reality book that brings dinosaurs to life using interactive technology. With a user-friendly app, kids can explore the world of dinosaurs in a fun and dynamic way. The app allows users to see the actual size of the dinosaurs and watch them come alive through videos and animations. It's an educational toy that combines augmented reality and traditional book reading, making learning about dinosaurs an exciting experience. Perfect for kids who love dinosaurs and anyone interested in augmented reality!

Key Features

  • Augmented reality
  • Virtual reality
  • Dinosaur book
  • Real life dinosaurs
  • Educational toy
  • Mind blowing book
  • Video book

Specifications

  • N/A

Pros

  • Fun and interactive way to learn about dinosaurs
  • User-friendly app with augmented reality technology
  • Shows actual size of dinosaurs

Cons

  • No specifications provided

Dinos By LeARnLab is an extraordinary augmented reality book that captivates kids and adults alike. It combines education and entertainment seamlessly, allowing children to learn about dinosaurs through interactive and immersive experiences. The user-friendly app brings the dinosaurs to life, providing a mind-blowing viewing experience with videos and animations. The feature that showcases the actual size of the dinosaurs adds an extra level of excitement and realism to the learning process. Whether you have a dinosaur enthusiast or simply want to explore the possibilities of augmented reality, this book is a fantastic choice. Be prepared to embark on an unforgettable journey into the prehistoric world!

Overall Score: 8.5/10

The Dinosaur Adventure Augmented Reality Coloring Book is a magical and educational tool for kids aged 4-8. With this coloring book, children can watch dinosaurs come to life in vibrant colors thanks to augmented reality technology. The book includes drawings of popular dinosaurs in their natural habitats, allowing kids to learn about their movements, eating habits, and more. It also comes with a set of washable markers and an AR mobile app that brings the child's creations to life. The book offers both physical and digital learning experiences, making it a valuable tool for early childhood development. With its engaging activities and educational content, this coloring book provides hours of fun and learning for young dinosaur enthusiasts.

Key Features

  • Watch dinosaurs come to life in vibrant colors
  • Drawings of popular dinosaurs in their habitats
  • Learn about dinosaur movements, eating habits, and more
  • Includes coloring pages, markers, learning games, and dinosaur facts
  • Compatible with Android and i OS devices

Specifications

  • Dimension: 12.20Lx9.00Wx0.75H
  • Size: Medium

Pros

  • Engaging and interactive learning experience
  • High-quality coloring pages and markers
  • Ability to print additional drawings for more fun
  • Compatible with both Android and i OS devices

Cons

  • Requires supervision to ensure optimal AR experience
  • Limited choices for additional drawings

The Dinosaur Adventure Augmented Reality Coloring Book combines creativity, technology, and educational content to provide an exciting and interactive learning experience for children. With its vibrant drawings, washable markers, and AR mobile app, kids can bring dinosaurs to life and learn about their world in a fun and engaging way. While supervision may be needed to ensure the best AR experience, the book offers a wide range of activities and facts to keep kids entertained and informed. The option to print additional drawings further extends the playability of this product. Overall, this coloring book is a fantastic tool for young dino enthusiasts who want to learn and play.

Overall Score: 9/10

The Dragon Defenders – Book Two: The Pitbull Returns is the second installment in The Dragon Defenders series, which is hailed as the world's first augmented reality novel series. This magical book captivates young readers, sparking their interest in reading without feeling like a chore. The story follows the adventures of Finn, Patty, Briar, and the dragons, featuring engaging language and interpersonal skills. The addition of in-book codes and maps that can be deciphered using a smartphone adds an element of interactive entertainment without distracting from the narrative. The book inspires children to cultivate their imagination and remain fascinated by the characters and storyline. While some readers appreciate the darker tone of the story, others find certain aspects unsettling. Overall, The Dragon Defenders – Book Two: The Pitbull Returns is a thrilling read that nourishes young minds and keeps them engaged.

Key Features

    Specifications

      Pros

      • Captivates young readers
      • Interactive AR experience with codes and maps
      • Engaging language and interpersonal skills
      • Inspires children to read and cultivate their imagination

      Cons

      • Some aspects may be unsettling for certain readers

      The Dragon Defenders – Book Two: The Pitbull Returns is a delightful installment in The Dragon Defenders series, providing young readers with an immersive and intellectually stimulating experience. The use of augmented reality through in-book codes and maps adds an extra layer of excitement to the storytelling. While the darker elements of the story may not appeal to everyone, the overall narrative encourages children to develop a love for reading, fostering their creativity and imagination. The characters are relatable and endearing, leaving readers eager to explore further adventures in the series. Whether read individually or with the help of a parent or tutor, this book is an excellent choice for sparking joy and curiosity in young minds.

      Overall Score: 9/10

      Step into a world of imagination and adventure with ARBI and the time machine – an Augmented Reality book that brings characters and stories to life through interactive experiences. Dive into a magical journey where the past and future collide, as you join ARBI and his friends on a quest to save the world. With stunning visuals and captivating storytelling, this book combines the traditional art of reading with modern technology, creating an immersive reading experience like no other. Get ready to embark on an extraordinary adventure, where the power of Augmented Reality brings magic and excitement to every page.

      Key Features

      • Augmented Reality book with interactive experiences
      • Combines traditional reading with modern technology
      • Immersive storytelling
      • Stunning visuals
      • Magical and exciting adventure

      Specifications

      • Dimension: 8.50Lx0.10Wx8.50H

      Pros

      • Engaging and interactive reading experience
      • Beautifully illustrated visuals
      • Brings characters and stories to life
      • Encourages creativity and imagination

      Cons

      • Requires compatible device for augmented reality features
      • Limited availability of AR content

      ARBI and the time machine is a captivating Augmented Reality book that takes storytelling to a whole new level. With its interactive experiences, stunning visuals, and immersive storytelling, this book offers an engaging and magical adventure for readers of all ages. While the augmented reality features require a compatible device, the traditional reading experience is still enjoyable without them. The book encourages creativity and imagination, making it a great choice for both kids and adults. Whether you’re a fan of technology or simply love a good story, ARBI and the time machine is a must-read that will transport you to a world filled with wonder and excitement.

      Overall Score: 9/10

      Tide Pools: An Augmented Reality Book is a new and immersive take on the traditional pop-up book. With the use of Augmented Reality (AR), every page comes to life through the free accompanying app. Readers can learn about ocean tides with interactive 3D models and tap objects in the app for more information. The book also features real video footage of tide pool locations in California, showcasing the fascinating marine life found there. With eye-catching illustrations and engaging content, this book provides a unique and educational experience for children. The app is easy to use and the combination of visuals, sounds, and narration makes it feel like you're actually at the ocean.

      Key Features

      • Immersive AR experience with the free app
      • Interactive 3D models explaining ocean tides
      • Real video footage of tide pool locations
      • Engaging illustrations and content

      Specifications

        Pros

        • Innovative and educational
        • Fascinating for kids and adults alike
        • Affordable technology
        • Brings the ocean to life

        Cons

        • Pricey
        • App compatibility issues on some devices

        Tide Pools: An Augmented Reality Book is a groundbreaking product that combines the traditional pop-up book format with Augmented Reality technology. It provides an immersive and interactive reading experience for children, allowing them to explore ocean tides and marine life in a way never seen before. The app integration and real video footage add an extra layer of realism to the book. Although it may be on the pricey side, the innovative features and educational value make it well worth the investment. With its engaging content and easy-to-use app, this book has the potential to inspire a love for the ocean and its creatures in young readers. Overall, Tide Pools: An Augmented Reality Book is a must-have for anyone seeking a unique and captivating reading experience.

        Overall Score: 9/10

        The Dragon Defenders – Book Five: The Grand Opening is the exciting finale to The Dragon Defenders novel series. In this augmented reality novel, the dragons are finally freed from the villain's control and soar back to their home. Packed with adventure, humor, and a captivating storyline, this book will keep young readers engaged till the very end. Author James Russell seamlessly integrates artificial intelligence to enhance the reading experience, making it even more entertaining and immersive. The Dragon Defenders – Book Five: The Grand Opening is perfect for children who are drawn to stories featuring dragons, action, and a touch of magic. Join the young protagonists on their thrilling journey and discover the epic conclusion to this popular series.

        Key Features

          Specifications

            Pros

              Cons

                The Dragon Defenders – Book Five: The Grand Opening is a highly recommended book for young readers who enjoy action-packed stories featuring dragons and adventure. With its captivating storyline, witty humor, and innovative use of augmented reality, it is no wonder that this series has garnered such positive reviews. Author James Russell has crafted a world that appeals to both children and adults, keeping readers hooked from start to finish. The inclusion of an interactive app brings an extra level of engagement and excitement to the reading experience. If you’re searching for a thrilling and entertaining series for your child, look no further than The Dragon Defenders.

                Overall Score: 8.5/10

                Step into a magical world with ARBI and discover the wonders of augmented reality. ARBI and the mysterious wizard is an engaging augmented reality book that combines storytelling with interactive technology. With ARBI, children can bring the characters and scenes to life through their smart devices, enhancing their reading experience. The book features captivating illustrations and a compelling story about a mysterious wizard. By scanning the pages, children can unlock hidden content, animated characters, and even play mini-games. ARBI Augmented Reality Books provide an innovative and immersive way for children to enjoy reading, fostering their imagination and curiosity.

                Key Features

                • Combines storytelling with interactive augmented reality technology
                • Captivating illustrations and engaging story about a mysterious wizard
                • Brings characters and scenes to life through smart devices
                • Unlock hidden content, animated characters, and mini-games

                Specifications

                • Dimension: 8.50Lx0.10Wx8.50H

                Pros

                • Innovative and immersive reading experience
                • Enhances children's imagination and curiosity
                • Engaging illustrations and interactive storytelling
                • Provides hidden content and mini-games for added fun

                Cons

                • Requires a smart device for augmented reality features
                • Limited to the storyline and content of the book

                ARBI and the mysterious wizard is a delightful augmented reality book that brings the magic of storytelling to life. Children will be enthralled by the captivating illustrations and the opportunity to interact with the characters and scenes through their smart devices. The augmented reality features provide an innovative and immersive reading experience, encouraging children to explore the book’s hidden content and engage in mini-games. While the book is limited to the storyline and content provided, it offers a unique way to foster children’s imagination and curiosity. ARBI Augmented Reality Books are a fantastic addition to any child’s reading collection, providing entertainment and educational value.

                Overall Score: 8/10

                ARBI and the Treasure Chest is a remarkable augmented reality book that combines physical and virtual worlds in a way like never before. By using the ARBI 2 app, the illustrations in the book come to life, allowing children to interact with the characters and experience the story in an engaging and captivating manner. The book emphasizes important life lessons such as friendship, teamwork, and acceptance, making it not only entertaining but also educational. Available in 9 different languages, ARBI and the Treasure Chest is recommended for children ages 6 to 12, but can be enjoyed by children of all ages. With its innovative use of technology, this book offers a unique reading experience that both children and parents will love.

                Key Features

                • Outstanding augmented reality book for children
                • Interactive app brings illustrations to life
                • Teaches valuable life lessons of friendship and teamwork
                • Available in 9 different languages
                • Recommended for children ages 6 to 12

                Specifications

                • Dimension: 8.50Lx0.12Wx8.50H

                Pros

                • App works great
                • Meaningful story
                • Cute graphics/characters
                • Great bonding activity with children

                Cons

                • App not available in App Store

                ARBI and the Treasure Chest is a groundbreaking augmented reality book that revolutionizes the way children read and engage with stories. The interactive app brings the illustrations to life, creating a magical and immersive experience. Not only does it entertain, but it also teaches valuable life lessons. The book is well-made, with cute graphics and characters that children will adore. While the app availability may be a downside for some, the overall experience of ARBI and the Treasure Chest is exceptional. It is a must-have for children who enjoy reading, and it makes a fantastic gift for any occasion. With its innovative use of technology and meaningful storytelling, ARBI and the Treasure Chest earns a high score of 8 out of 10.

                Overall Score: 8/10

                One Wacky Week: An Augmented Reality Book is a delightful storybook that combines beautiful artwork with augmented reality technology. Designed to entertain and inspire children, each page features colorful art that comes to life when viewed through the accompanying app. The author has created a charming collection of short stories and poems, accompanied by playful illustrations. The book also serves as a great way to spark children's imagination by introducing them to art, storytelling, and technology. With the interactive animations and the author's storytelling in the app, reading becomes a captivating experience. The book is larger than expected, making it perfect for shared reading and art 'animation' viewing. While some reviewers praise the book for its creativity and potential to motivate young readers, others criticize the inclusion of unrelated content and question the true nature of augmented reality in the book.

                Key Features

                  Specifications

                  • Dimension: 8.50Lx0.07Wx11.00H

                  Pros

                    Cons

                      One Wacky Week: An Augmented Reality Book is an imaginative and engaging book that incorporates both traditional storytelling and modern technology. The combination of delightful artwork and interactive animations through the accompanying app provides a unique reading experience for children. The book can inspire young readers to explore their creativity and learn about the possibilities of augmented reality. However, it’s worth noting that some readers found the inclusion of unrelated content and the limited nature of the augmented reality experience to be disappointing. Overall, One Wacky Week is a fun and educational book that can captivate young imaginations and encourage their interest in art, writing, and technology.

                      Overall Score: 7.5/10

                      ARBI and the Fire Breathing Dragon is an augmented reality book that combines a cute storyline with interactive 3D imagery. The book tells the tale of a happy village threatened by a fire-breathing dragon and a heroic knight who sets out to save the day. With the ARBI app, readers can bring the colorful illustrations to life and watch as the characters move and the scenery transforms into a 3D world. The book also teaches important lessons about cooperation and understanding. Although some reviewers felt the story and AR quality were lacking, overall, it offers an engaging and technologically innovative experience for tech-savvy children.

                      Key Features

                      • Combines a traditional book with augmented reality technology
                      • Interactive 3D imagery that comes to life with the ARBI app
                      • Colorful illustrations and engaging storyline
                      • Teaches important lessons about cooperation and understanding

                      Specifications

                      • Dimension: 8.50Lx0.10Wx8.50H

                      Pros

                      • Engaging and fun for tech-savvy children
                      • Colorful and well-drawn illustrations
                      • Teaches important lessons about cooperation
                      • High-quality paperback book

                      Cons

                      • Some reviewers found the story uninteresting
                      • AR quality may not be up to everyone's expectations
                      • AR app may have issues with older devices

                      ARBI and the Fire Breathing Dragon is an innovative combination of a traditional book and augmented reality technology. It offers children a fun and immersive reading experience, bringing the colorful illustrations to life through the ARBI app. While the story may not be the most creative or engaging for some, the interactive 3D imagery adds an extra layer of excitement. The book also imparts important lessons about cooperation and understanding, making it both entertaining and educational. Although the AR quality and compatibility with older devices may be a drawback, overall, ARBI and the Fire Breathing Dragon is a recommended choice for tech-savvy children who enjoy exploring the possibilities of augmented reality in literature.

                      Overall Score: 9/10

                      Reptiles & Amphibians: An Augmented Reality Popup Book is an interactive and educational book that brings every page to life through augmented reality. Perfect for the classroom, this book allows readers to see real video footage of reptiles and amphibians by using the free app from the Apple App Store or Google Play Store. With its wire binding and heavier paper, the book maintains its shape as you turn each page. This book is a great purchase for young, imaginative readers and even adults who are captivated by its magic. It receives a customer rating of 4.7/5.

                      Key Features

                      • Augmented Reality brings every page to life
                      • Interactive & Educational
                      • Perfect for the Classroom
                      • Download the free app from the Apple App Store or Google Play Store
                      • See real video footage of reptiles and amphibians

                      Specifications

                      • N/A

                      Pros

                      • Enchanting experience for young readers
                      • Sturdy construction with wire binding
                      • Real video footage brings illustrations to life

                      Cons

                      • Boring voiceover narration
                      • Limited use of AR feature
                      • Possible loading issues with the app

                      Reptiles & Amphibians: An Augmented Reality Popup Book is a must-have for young readers who are fascinated by the world of reptiles and amphibians. The combination of stunning illustrations and augmented reality technology makes this book a truly immersive and educational experience. The book’s sturdy construction ensures durability, while the real video footage brings the creatures to life in astonishing detail. Although the voiceover narration may be lackluster and the AR feature could have been utilized more creatively, overall, this book is a fantastic addition to any child’s library. With the potential for future updates and new releases from the same company, it’s an exciting glimpse into the future of interactive storytelling.

                      Overall Score: 8/10

                      Augmented Reality is an exciting book that brings a new level of interactivity to your smartphone or tablet. With over 30 cool and interactive 3D objects, you can create surprising and funny pictures using augmented reality technology. Simply use a QR code reader to launch the AR experience in your browser, no special app required. The book provides endless fun and allows you to capture photos and videos of your creations. The only requirement is a new Android phone or tablet with Android 7+. Get ready to explore a world of augmented reality with Augmented Reality – Create surprising and funny pictures with AR!

                      Key Features

                      • Augmented reality book for smartphones and tablets
                      • Over 30 cool and interactive 3D objects to play with

                      Specifications

                      • Dimension: 6.00Lx0.17Wx9.00H

                      Pros

                      • Entertaining and fun experience
                      • No special app required, runs in browser with QR code reader
                      • Allows for capturing photos and videos

                      Cons

                      • Requires a new Android phone or tablet (Android 7+)

                      Augmented Reality is a highly entertaining and interactive book that brings augmented reality to life on your smartphone or tablet. With its wide variety of cool and interactive 3D objects, users can create surprising and funny pictures while having a lot of fun. The fact that it runs in a browser with just a QR code reader is a major plus, as it eliminates the need for a specific app. However, it’s worth noting that it requires a newer Android device, which may be a limitation for some users. Overall, Augmented Reality is a recommended choice for those looking to explore the possibilities of augmented reality on their mobile devices.

                      Overall Score: 6.8/10

                      Explore the world of predators through this interactive book that utilizes augmented reality technology. Predators: Unleash Huge Augmented Reality Beasts (iExplore) allows users to bring virtual creatures to life in their own surroundings using a companion app. The book has received positive reviews from children as it serves as an exciting and educational learning tool. However, some customers have been disappointed with the app's functionality, stating that it frequently crashes or is not available for certain devices. Overall, the book provides an engaging experience for young animal enthusiasts, although the reliability of the app may vary.

                      Key Features

                      • Augmented reality book featuring predators
                      • Utilizes a companion app for interactive experience
                      • Exciting and rewarding for young learners

                      Specifications

                      • Dimension: 10.30Lx0.50Wx9.10H

                      Pros

                      • Engaging learning tool for children
                      • Realistic augmented reality experience
                      • Captivating interactive book

                      Cons

                      • App frequently crashes or does not work
                      • Limited availability for certain devices

                      Predators: Unleash Huge Augmented Reality Beasts (iExplore) offers an immersive and educational experience for young readers. While the companion app may have some issues, the book itself provides an engaging journey into the world of predators. With its interactive approach, children can learn about these creatures while seeing them come alive in their own environment. Although the reliability of the app may vary, this book is still a great choice for young animal enthusiasts who want to explore the wonders of augmented reality.

                      Overall Score: 8/10

                      Space Race (Augmented Reality) is an immersive and educational book that brings the wonders of space exploration to life. With the help of augmented reality technology, readers can unlock an interactive experience and delve deeper into the mysteries of the universe. However, some users have reported that the AR videos may take some time to load, and the content in the book might be too advanced for very young children. Nevertheless, the book offers informative and engaging content, making it an excellent choice for children with a keen interest in space. Let your child's imagination soar as they embark on a thrilling space adventure!

                      Key Features

                      • Augmented reality brings space exploration to life
                      • Informative and educational content
                      • Suitable for children with an interest in space
                      • Engaging app for exploring the depths of space

                      Specifications

                      • Dimension: 8.78Lx0.47Wx11.14H

                      Pros

                      • Informative and educational book
                      • Engaging app for interactive learning
                      • Stimulates interest in space exploration

                      Cons

                      • AR videos take time to load
                      • May be too advanced for young children
                      • Limited variety of augmented reality footage

                      Space Race (Augmented Reality) is a captivating book that successfully combines education and entertainment. While there may be some minor issues with the AR videos, the book overall provides an informative and interactive experience for young space enthusiasts. With its engaging content and stimulating approach to learning, this book is a great educational tool that sparks curiosity and fosters a love for space exploration. Whether your child dreams of becoming an astronaut or simply wants to learn more about the universe, Space Race (Augmented Reality) is an excellent choice to ignite their imagination and fuel their thirst for knowledge.

                      Buyer's Guide: Augmented Reality Books

                      Welcome to the ultimate buyer's guide for augmented reality books! In this guide, we will explore everything you need to know about this exciting technology and provide you with some helpful tips. So, let's dive right in:

                      Benefits of Augmented Reality Books

                      • Immersive Learning: Augmented reality books bring concepts to life by overlaying interactive digital elements on printed pages, enhancing engagement and understanding.
                      • Interactive Experience: With AR books, readers can actively participate in the storytelling process, unlocking hidden content, playing games, and solving puzzles.
                      • Visual and Auditory Stimulation: This technology creates a multisensory experience, combining visuals, animations, sounds, and even haptic feedback to make learning more enjoyable.
                      • Flexible Learning: AR books cater to different learning styles, accommodating both visual learners who benefit from the interactive digital content and text-based learners who prefer reading.
                      • Engagement and Motivation: By blending traditional books with cutting-edge technology, AR books ignite curiosity and motivate readers to explore and learn in unique ways.

                      Considerations before Purchasing

                      • Age Appropriate: Consider the age range for which the AR book is designed. Some books cater to young children with simplified interactions, while others target older readers with more complex content.
                      • Compatibility: Check if the AR book is compatible with the device you intend to use. Some books work with specific smartphones or tablets, while others require dedicated AR hardware.
                      • Content Quality: Assess the quality of the digital content. Look for well-executed animations, accurate information, and engaging interactive elements that enhance the learning experience.
                      • Ease of Use: Evaluate how user-friendly the AR book is. Opt for books with intuitive controls and instructions, allowing children and adults alike to navigate the augmented reality seamlessly.
                      • Battery Life: If the AR book relies on a device with limited battery life, ensure it will last throughout the reading session or consider purchasing an external battery pack.

                      Factors to Compare While Choosing

                      1. Content Variety: Look for AR books that cover a wide range of topics, from science and history to literature and art. Diversity in content allows for a more comprehensive learning experience.
                      2. Interactivity Levels: Some AR books offer a deeper level of interaction, allowing readers to manipulate objects, change perspectives, or create their own stories. Consider your preference for interactivity when selecting a book.
                      3. Replay Value: Check if the AR book provides long-term value. Books with multiple interactive elements, branching narratives, or different outcomes encourage replayability and further exploration.
                      4. User Reviews: Always read user reviews before making a purchase. Pay attention to feedback regarding content quality, compatibility, ease of use, and overall satisfaction with the augmented reality experience.
                      5. Price: Compare prices across various AR books. Consider the overall value for money, including the quality and quantity of content, level of interactivity, and the intended age range.

                      Frequently Asked Questions about 14 Best Augmented Reality Books for 2023

                      Can I use augmented reality books without any additional devices?

                      Yes, some AR books utilize the camera and sensors on smartphones or tablets to overlay digital content on printed pages. However, certain books may require dedicated AR hardware.

                      Which devices are compatible with augmented reality books?

                      Compatibility varies across AR books. Some are designed specifically for certain smartphone models or tablets, while others work with a broader range of devices. Always check the compatibility requirements before purchasing.

                      Are augmented reality books suitable for all age groups?

                      While augmented reality books are designed for various age ranges, it’s essential to consider the complexity of the content and the level of interactivity. Some books may be more suitable for children, while others cater to adults or specific educational levels.

                      Do augmented reality books require an internet connection?

                      It depends on the book and the nature of the augmented reality content. Some books may require an internet connection to download additional digital assets or access online features, while others can function offline once the initial content is downloaded.

                      Can I create my own augmented reality books?

                      While it is possible to create custom augmented reality experiences, developing a full-fledged AR book typically requires specialized tools and knowledge. Some platforms allow you to add digital content to existing books, but creating an entire AR book from scratch can be quite challenging.